Signal vs 1Password
Based on our analysis, Signal is the more privacy-respecting choice overall.
BACK →| Category | Signal | 1Password |
|---|---|---|
| Overall | A · 87/100 | B · 74/100 |
| What they collect | Positive (88) | Mixed (78) |
| Who they share it with | Positive (88) | Mixed (65) |
| What you can do | Mixed (78) | Mixed (73) |
| What they promise | Positive (86) | Mixed (76) |
Signal is a nonprofit that genuinely cannot read your messages or listen to your calls — the encryption is architectural, not a promise — but it requires a real phone number to register, is subject to US law, and its privacy policy is conspicuously sparse: it hasn't been substantively updated since 2018 and lacks the specific retention periods, GDPR rights, or DPO contact that more thorough policies provide.
View full analysis →1Password can never read your saved passwords — they're end-to-end encrypted and even 1Password holds no keys — but outside the vault, the company collects substantial usage and diagnostic data, shares information with advertising partners in ways that may legally count as a data sale, and applies vague retention language to everything that isn't your vault content.
View full analysis →