Based on our analysis, Proton is the more privacy-respecting choice overall.
BACK →Overall
Proton
A · 88/100Fastmail
B+ · 79/100What they collect
Proton
Positive (90)
Fastmail
Mixed (74)
Who they share it with
Proton
Positive (82)
Fastmail
Mixed (76)
What you can do
Proton
Positive (84)
Fastmail
Positive (82)
What they promise
Proton
Positive (86)
Fastmail
Mixed (80)
| Category | Proton | Fastmail |
|---|---|---|
| Overall | A · 88/100 | B+ · 79/100 |
| What they collect | Positive (90) | Mixed (74) |
| Who they share it with | Positive (82) | Mixed (76) |
| What you can do | Positive (84) | Positive (82) |
| What they promise | Positive (86) | Mixed (80) |
Proton collects as little as technically possible, can't read your encrypted content even if asked, is governed by strict Swiss law, and gives you real control — the rare case where the privacy policy matches the privacy pitch.
View full analysis →Fastmail is a paid email provider that doesn't sell your data or serve ads, has clear retention periods and a transparency report — but unlike Proton, staff can technically access your emails, data moves through US and Indian infrastructure, and IP logs are kept for a year.
View full analysis →You might also want to compare